Back to Blogs
16 November 2026

Dating Again: When Do You Mention Toys?

I can write a whole blog about men’s pleasure without getting too embarrassed these days.

Ask me to mention a sex toy to someone I’ve only recently started dating, though, and apparently I’ve forgotten how normal conversations work.

I’m 38. I’ve had relationships. I’ve had awkward conversations about money, family, exes and whose turn it is to clean the bathroom.

You’d think I’d be reasonably equipped to have a grown-up conversation about something I might enjoy.

Apparently not.

Because when you’re dating someone new, there’s that strange period where you’re trying to be yourself while also being a slightly more presentable version of yourself.

The version who remembers to change his bedsheets.

And somewhere in amongst all that, there’s a question I’ve been thinking about.

When do you actually mention sex toys in a new relationship?

Not because there’s some big secret to reveal. More because I don’t particularly fancy making someone uncomfortable over a perfectly ordinary conversation.

And, if I’m being completely truthful, I don’t much fancy being judged either.

Why Does Mentioning a Toy Feel Like Such a Big Confession?

I’ve thought about this more than I probably should.

If someone I’m dating tells me they’ve got a particular hobby, I’m unlikely to give it much thought.

Unless it’s competitive ironing. I’d have questions.

But mention that I might own or be curious about a sex toy, and suddenly my brain treats it like I’m about to disclose something terribly significant.

Why?

I reckon a lot of it comes down to how blokes grow up thinking about pleasure.

We’re supposed to be confident. Supposed to know what we’re doing. Supposed to have everything worked out without ever needing to ask a question.

And toys?

For years, I had this daft idea that they were something men weren’t really meant to need.

I’ve talked about this before in The Sock-Drawer Era: How Shame Shows Up in Small Ways.

It’s surprising how much energy can go into keeping something ordinary hidden, even when nobody’s actually asked us to hide it.

What I’m starting to realise is that privacy and shame aren’t the same thing.

I don’t have to announce every personal detail to someone I’ve just met.

But equally, I don’t need to act as though my curiosity is something embarrassing.

There’s a difference.

Took me long enough to work that out.

So, When Is the Right Time to Mention Toys?

This was the bit I really wanted an answer to.

Is it after three dates? A month? Once things become exclusive?

Do I need to wait until we’re comfortable enough to discuss what we’re having for tea without pretending we’re both adventurous eaters?

I went looking for a rule.

There isn’t one.

And actually, I’m quite glad.

The right time to talk about sex toys in a new relationship is when there’s enough trust and comfort for an honest conversation, without either person feeling pressured.

That might happen relatively early. It might take a while.

It depends on the people involved, how the relationship is developing and whether talking about intimacy already feels natural.

Personally, I wouldn’t bring it up on a first date purely because I felt I ought to.

I’m still trying to establish whether we both find the same things funny.

But I also wouldn’t deliberately keep it hidden for months because I was worried about what someone might think.

There’s a Difference Between Being Honest and Telling Someone Everything:

This is something I wish I’d understood earlier.

Being open in a relationship doesn’t mean immediately sharing every thought, preference or personal experience.

Some things are private until there’s a reason to discuss them.

If I’m using a toy on my own, that doesn’t automatically mean it needs to become a relationship announcement.

If I’m interested in trying something together, though, that’s different.

Now there’s another person involved. Their comfort, interest and boundaries matter just as much as mine.

That’s when a proper conversation becomes important.

Not a dramatic confession.

Just a conversation.

How I’d Actually Bring It Up Without Making It Weird:

I used to think conversations about sex needed to sound confident.

You know the sort of thing.

Casual. Smooth. Like someone in a television drama who has never stumbled over a sentence in his life.

That is not me.

If I tried to deliver a carefully rehearsed speech about sexual preferences, I’d probably sound like I was giving a presentation at work.

“So, moving on to slide four…”

No, thanks.

I’ve realised I’d rather sound slightly awkward and genuine than confident and completely unlike myself.

Start With Curiosity, Not a Grand Announcement:

If the subject came up naturally, I might say something like:

“I’ve got a bit more open-minded about toys over the last few years. Is that something you’ve ever talked about with someone?”

That’s it.

Nothing particularly clever.

I’m not asking for an immediate decision. I’m not suggesting we need to do anything.

I’m just opening up a conversation.

Another possibility might be:

“I used to think toys weren’t really something blokes talked about. I’ve changed my mind a bit.”

That feels more like something I’d actually say.

And it gives the other person a chance to respond without feeling they’re being asked to agree to anything.

Give the Other Person Room to Have Their Own Opinion:

This is probably more important than finding the perfect words.

If someone I’m dating looks surprised, that doesn’t automatically mean they’ve judged me.

Maybe they haven’t thought about it before.

Maybe they’ve had a previous experience that makes them cautious.

Maybe they’re curious themselves.

Or maybe they’re simply not interested.

All reasonable possibilities.

I’d rather have the conversation somewhere relaxed, away from a moment where either person might feel expected to act on it.

And if the answer is no?

Then it’s no.

I don’t need to turn it into a debate, make a joke to cover my embarrassment or keep trying to change their mind.

There’s nothing particularly romantic about being talked into something.

What If They Think It’s Strange?

Right.

This is the uncomfortable bit.

Because despite everything I’ve learned, I still care what someone I like thinks of me.

Of course I do.

When you’re dating again, rejection already feels like a possibility lurking somewhere in the background.

You start wondering whether you’ve talked too much, said something stupid or worn the wrong shirt.

Adding a conversation about sex toys into the mix can feel like giving someone another reason to decide you’re not for them.

But I’ve been thinking about something I wrote in 5 Things I Wish Someone Told Me About Men’s Pleasure.

For years, I connected being a man with having to appear completely confident about sex.

As though admitting curiosity meant admitting something was missing.

I don’t see it that way now.

Being interested in toys doesn’t automatically say anything about how masculine I am, how attracted I am to someone or whether a relationship is satisfying.

It’s simply one part of what I might enjoy.

A new partner might feel differently about it.

And that matters.

But there’s a difference between respecting someone’s preferences and deciding there’s something wrong with mine.

I’m trying to remember that.

Especially when my brain starts doing its usual worst-case-scenario routine.

If You’re Both Curious, Keep It Simple:

Let’s say the conversation goes well.

Nobody’s uncomfortable. Nobody’s making assumptions. There’s genuine curiosity on both sides.

What then?

I think my old instinct would have been to overcomplicate things.

Read seventeen articles. Compare products. Worry about choosing the wrong thing.

Basically turn a fairly straightforward subject into a research project.

Which, to be fair, is something I’m quite good at.

These days I’d keep it much simpler.

I’ve already written about beginner-friendly options in Beginner Toys I’d Recommend to Any Bloke, and I’d still start with the same general approach.

Nothing too complicated. Nothing bought to impress someone.

Just something suitable for beginners, if both people genuinely want to explore the idea.

A few practical things matter here.

Choosing body-safe materials from a reputable seller makes sense. So does reading the instructions, keeping toys properly cleaned and checking whether a lubricant is suitable for the toy’s material.

Water-based lube is often a useful beginner-friendly option, depending on the product and its instructions.

Going slowly matters too.

And if something hurts, stopping is the sensible response. Persistent pain is a reason to speak to a healthcare professional, not push through it.

If considering an anal toy, a properly flared base is essential.

None of this needs to be complicated.

Most importantly, agreeing to talk about toys isn’t the same as agreeing to use one.

Either person can change their mind.

And honestly, if all that happens is we have a comfortable conversation about something we used to find awkward, I’d consider that a decent outcome.

There’s no relationship checklist to complete.

Five Things I’d Remind Myself Before Having That Conversation:

I’ve spent enough time overthinking this to come up with a few things I’d want to remember.

  1. There’s no compulsory timeline
  2. Personal curiosity isn’t a confession
  3. A conversation isn’t an expectation
  4. Someone else’s boundaries matter as much as mine
  5. A slightly awkward conversation can still be a good one

I think the biggest change for me is realising I don’t have to choose between keeping everything private and announcing every personal detail.

There’s a middle ground.

I can get to know someone. Build a bit of trust. See how comfortable we are talking about things that matter.

And when it feels right, I can mention toys without treating the subject like a terrible secret.

I’m not suddenly going to become one of those blokes who can discuss absolutely anything without getting embarrassed.

Unlikely, at 38.

And I still wouldn’t bring it up halfway through ordering a pint.

But if I’m seeing someone I genuinely like, and we’re comfortable enough to talk about intimacy, I don’t think I’d spend quite so long worrying about finding the perfect moment.

Tom
By Tom

I’m Tom. 38. An everyday bloke who spent years thinking toys were “not for men like me.” I’m writing because I’m done letting embarrassment run my sex life — and I know loads of men feel the same. I want to make men’s pleasure feel normal, practical, and shame-free.