What’s the Best Material for Your Strap-On Dildo? A No-Nonsense Breakdown

Let’s talk about something that doesn’t always get the attention it deserves: material.

Because while size, shape, and colour get all the hype, the material your strap-on dildo is made from can seriously affect:
• Comfort
• Safety
• Sensation
• Ease of cleaning

If you’ve ever wondered why some toys feel amazing and others… not so much, this is usually why.

Why Material Actually Matters

A strap-on dildo isn’t just something you use once and forget about. It’s something that comes into close contact with sensitive areas — sometimes for extended periods.

The right material should feel:
• Comfortable against the body
• Easy to clean thoroughly
• Durable over time
• Safe for repeated use

In short: your body deserves better than guesswork.

Silicone: The Gold Standard for Most People

If you see “body-safe silicone,” that’s usually a very good sign.

Why silicone is so popular:
• Non-porous (doesn’t trap bacteria)
• Soft but supportive
• Comfortable for most bodies
• Easy to clean
• Long-lasting

Silicone strap-on dildos come in a huge range of firmness levels — from soft and flexible to firm and structured — which makes them ideal for beginners and experienced users alike.

Good to know:
Stick to water-based lubricant with silicone toys to keep them in great condition.

Rubber, Jelly & TPE: What to Know Before You Buy

Some strap-on dildos are made from softer, more flexible materials like rubber or TPE.

They can feel:
• Very squishy
• Realistic in texture
• More budget-friendly

However, these materials are often porous, meaning they can absorb bacteria and odours over time.

That doesn’t mean they’re “bad” — just that they require:
• Extra careful cleaning
• Individual use only
• More frequent replacement

If hygiene and longevity are top priorities, many people choose silicone instead.

Glass & Metal (Yes, Really)

While less common for strap-on play, glass and metal dildos do exist and are sometimes used with compatible harness systems.

Why people like them:
• Completely non-porous
• Extremely easy to clean
• Can be warmed or cooled for temperature play

They tend to be:
• Heavier
• Very firm
• Better suited to experienced users

Not usually a first-time choice, but definitely loved by some.

Firmness: Just as Important as Material

Material affects firmness — and firmness affects control.

General rule of thumb:
• Softer = more flexible, less control
• Medium-firm = balanced and beginner-friendly
• Very firm = maximum control, more intense sensation

For strap-on play, many people prefer medium-firm because it’s easier to guide without feeling rigid or uncomfortable.

Skin Sensitivity & Allergies

If you or your partner have sensitive skin, material choice becomes even more important.

Helpful tips:
• Avoid heavily scented or novelty materials
• Choose smooth, high-quality finishes
• Patch-test if you’re unsure
• Stop using anything that causes irritation

Comfort is never something to “push through.”

Cleaning & Care by Material

No matter what you choose, proper care makes all the difference.

General guidance:
• Clean after every use
• Use warm water and mild, unscented soap or toy cleaner
• Dry thoroughly before storing
• Store separately if possible

Non-porous materials are easier to keep hygienic long-term — which is why they’re often recommended.

So… What’s the “Best” Material?

There’s no single right answer — but for most people, especially beginners:

Silicone ticks the most boxes.

It’s comfortable, safe, versatile, and easy to look after. From there, you can always explore different textures or firmness levels as your preferences evolve.

Final Thoughts: Choose What Feels Good and Makes Sense

The best strap-on dildo material is one that:
• Feels good on your body
• Fits your experience level
• Matches your comfort with cleaning and care
• Makes you feel confident using it

Pleasure should never come with uncertainty.